| Deacons |
(as of 1993)
| Henry Whitfield | 1643 - 1650 | Senior |
| John Higginson | 1653 - 1660 | Senior |
| Joseph Elion | 1665 - 1694 | Senior |
| Thomas Ruggles, Sr. | 1695 - 1728 | Senior |
| Thomas Ruggles, Jr. | 1729 - 1756 | Senior |
| Amos Fowler | 1757 - 1800 | Senior |
| Israel Brainard | 1800 - 1806 | Senior |
| Aaron Dutton | 1806 - 1842 | Senior |
| E. Edwin Hall | 1843 - 1855 | Senior |
| Henry Wickes | 1856 - 1858 | Senior |
| William S. Smith | 1859 - 1865 | Senior |
| Cornelius L. Kitchell | 1870 - 1873 | Senior |
| Theodore L. Day | 1874 - 1877 | Senior |
| Henry O. Fitch | 1878 - 1879 | Senior |
| Frank H. Taylor | 1880 - 1883 | Senior |
| Edmund M. Vittum | 1884 - 1888 | Senior |
| Frederick E. Snow | 1891 - 1920 | Senior |
| David N. Beach, Jr. | 1921 - 1924 | Senior |
| William C. H. Moe | 1925 - 1948 | Senior |
| Paul F. Battenhouse | 1948 - 1952 | Senior |
| William V. North | 1952 - 1963 | Senior |
| C. Freeman Sleeper | 1958 | Assistant |
| Claiborne Bell | 1958 - 1959 | Assistant |
| Andrew Mason | 1960 - 1963 | Assistant |
| H. McElwaine Helms | 1963 - 1974 | Senior |
| Stephen Whetstone | 1963 - 1966 | Assistant |
| Noel Bishop | 1966 - 1968 | Assistant |
| Ronald A. Rising | 1969 - 1972 | Assistant |
| Timothy E. Haut | 1972 - 1974 | Assistant |
| Gerald Parker | 1974 | Interim |
| Edward R. Lincoln | 1975 - 1987 | Senior |
| Douglas J. House | 1976 | Intern |
| Kendrick L. Norris | 1977 - 1987 | Associate |
| Alan C. Mermann | 1979 | Assistant |
| Kendrick L. Norris | 1987 - | Senior |
| Martha Eidmann | 1987 | Interim |
| Peg Stearn | 1988 - | Associate |