| Descendants |
(R) = Removed [X] = Resigned
Deacons between 1664 - 1907 were life terms
[*] = FIRST FEMALE DEACON
| George Bartlett | 1664-1669 | Charles W. Cooke | 1921-1932 |
| John Fowler | 1664-1676 | Horace C. Dudley | 1921-1936 |
| John Graves | 1666-1695 | Frederic G. Davis | 1932-1963 |
| William Johnson | 1673-1702 | R. Walter Bishop | 1924-1962 |
| John Meigs | 1696-1713 | Read I. Ripley | 1936-1942 |
| Samuel Johnson | 1713-1727 | Lawrence R. Leete. Sr. | 1936-1950 |
| James Hooke | 1702-1742 | John C. Carr | 1948-1954 |
| Thomas Hall | 1727-1753 | Theodore Persons | 1951-1960 |
| William Seward | 1730-1764 | Richmond Curtiss | 1951-1957 |
| Timothy Stone | 1742-1765 | Myron D. Hager | 1954-1955 |
| Dr. Nathaniel Ruggles | 1751-1794 | William E. Pinchbeck | 1955-1963 |
| Ebenezer Bartlett | 1765-1775 | James E. Rolston | 1956-1963 |
| John Burgis | 1775-1799 | Daniel Reinhardsen, Jr. | 1956-1958 |
| Thomas Burgis | 1794-1799 | Norman W. Knowles | 1956-1962 |
| Samuel Chittenden | 1799-1802 | Richard Guptil | 1957-1961 |
| Abraham Chittenden | 1799-1848 | Lee Appleton | 1958-1960 |
| David Bishop(R) | 1802-1807 | Carl G. Rosenquist | 1960-1964 |
| Ambrose Leete | 1807-1809 | Dr. Alan C. Mermann | 1961-1974 |
| Thomas Hart | 1809-1829 | Edward Chapin | 1961-1964 |
| Anson Chittenden (R) | 1809-1813 | J. Harold Rossiter | 1962-1976 |
| William Starr | 1813-1830 | Stuart D. Burt, Jr. | 1962-1965 |
| John B. Chittenden (R) | 1823-1831 | Oliver E. Slocum | 1963-1972 |
| Comfort Starr | 1827-1862 | Gustaf R. Bodin | 1964-1972 |
| Jason Seward (R) | 1827-1839 | Leon P. Taylor | 1963-1972 |
| Abraham Dudley | 1827-1852 | Frederick T. Garry | 1963-1964 |
| Samuel Robinson | 1832-1839 | William T. Burton | 1965-1965 |
| Albert A. Leete | 1832-1888 | William E. Pinchbeck | 1966-1972 |
| Edward L. Leete | 1852-1884 | Ellsworth Brown | 1963-1965 |
| Eli Parmelee | 1852-1882 | Warren H. Terrell, Jr. | 1965-1969 |
| Edwin O. Davis | 1871-1907 | Alfred W. House | 1966-1983 |
| John Graves | 1877-1883 | Howard C. Angell, Jr. | 1966-1972 |
| John William Norton | 1877-1925 | Albert Bishop | 1966-1974 |
| E. Walter Leete | 1883-1907 | John Gibson | 1966-1970 |
| William A. Dudley | 1905-1947 | Edward M. Petzoldt | 1969-1973 |
| Charles D. Hubbard | 1907-1951 | John H. Hall, Sr. | 1966-1970 |
| Lewis C. Wilcox | 1907-1922 | Donald M. Cunningham | 1966-1970 |
DEACONS OF THE FIRST CHURCH (CONTINUED)
| Elton L. Helander | 1969-1974 | Stephen B. Dudley | 1983-1989 |
| David Reynolds | 1969-1972 | June Y. Park | 1983-1986 |
| William G. Farrar | 1970-1976 | Fred Sibley | 1983-1986 |
| Edward Jessop | 1970-1972 | Donald Burch | 1984-1986 |
| Worth L. Cox | 1970-1977 | Rebecca Mars | 1984-1987 |
| Florian Fox | 1971-1979 | Carol Luckenback | 1984-1986 |
| Thomas Mitchell | 1971-1975 | Norman R. Zabel | 1984-1987 |
| Elizabeth J. Brown. [*] | 1971-1982 | Dr. Diane Komp | 1985-1991 |
| Dr. Frederic Anderson | 1972-1980 | Alice M. Mitchell | 1985-1991 |
| William Park | 1972-1980 | John R. Eismeier | 1985-1991 |
| Gustaf H. Bodin, Sr. | 1972-1975 | Thomas Pugh | 1985-1991 |
| Barbara Booth | 1974-1977 | Gladys Holland | 1985-1990 |
| Walser W. Janeway.. | 1974-1980 | Peter Rebuzzini | 1986-1992 |
| Eric V. Sandin | 1975-1977 | Carin Small | 1986-1992 |
| John C. Gerkin | 1975-1978 | Dr. Gordon Strothers[X] | 1986-1988 |
| H. Dale Freidag | 1975-1978 | Elizabeth Barnes | 1987-1990 |
| Jean Jessop | 1975-1978 | Hal Boutwell[X] | 1987-1987 |
| Anne B. Carter | 1975-1978 | Eric Sandin | 1987-1990 |
| H. Philip Dudley | 1976-1982 | Christina H. Wilcox | 1987-1990 |
| William A. Russell.. | 1976-1979 | Dr. Kyle Pruett | 1988-1995 |
| Rufus B. Bishop | 1977-1980 | Charlotte White | 1989-1995 |
| Harvey W. Robb | 1978-1981 | Richmond Curtiss | 1990-1991 |
| Anne Conover | 1978-1984 | Frederic Anderson | 1990-1993 |
| Frederick E. Moore | 1978-1981 | Albert Bishop | 1990-1993 |
| Harriet W. Pinchbeck | 1976-1981 | Barbara Riley | 1990-1993 |
| Dr. Richard A. Small | 1977-1980 | Jean Young | 1990-1996 |
| Robert J. Pleasure | 1976-1981 | Jan Campaigne | 1991-1994 |
| Vern H. Fox | 1976-1982 | William Farrar | 1991-1994 |
| Ethel H. MacGregor | 1979-1985 | William Huhn | 1991-1994 |
| John Barto | 1980-1983 | Gladys Minear | 1991-1994 |
| William Davison | 1980-1983 | Constance Swett | 1992-1995 |
| William Crawford | 1980-1986 | DeWitt Zuse | 1992-1995 |
| Robert Campaigne | 1981-1987 | Esther Prisloe | 1993-1993 |
| Lewis S. Holland | 1981-1984 | Ellen Burt | 1993-1996 |
| Dr. Paul Minear | 1981-1984 | Warren Jillson | 1993-1996 |
| James Nelmes | 1982-1985 | David Johnson | 1993-1996 |
| Basil Duncan. | 1982-1985 |